September 2025 Celebrity Book Club Spoilers
Looking for the September 2025 Celebrity Book Club Spoilers? You’ve come to the right place! For years, I’ve worked with sources in the book industry to bring you these spoilers before they are announced so you can get ahead on library holds and preorders.
Once again, I’ve rounded up the books that will be chosen as September 2025 book club picks by the Reese Witherspoon, Oprah, Read with Jenna, and GMA Book Clubs. These have NOT yet been officially released (as of now, they are all being announced on September 2) but I am fairly confident in our intel.
While you are waiting to read these releases, I suggest using these spoilers to put in your library holds early and get to the front of the list. You can also check out the rest of the September 2025 new book releases.
September 2025 Celebrity Book Club Spoilers
Reese Witherspoon Book Club Pick
To The Moon and Back by Eliana Ramage – Jump to read synopsis
Read with Jenna Book Club Pick
Buckeye: A Novel by Patrick Ryan – Jump to read synopsis
Good Morning America Book Club Pick
The Lost Hours by Hayley Gelfuso- Jump to section for more info
Good Morning America YA Book Club Pick
Sisters in the Wind by Angeline Boulley – Jump to section for more info
Oprah Book Club Pick
All the Way to the River by Elizabeth Gilbert – Jump to read synopsis
*This post contains affiliate links. Purchases made through links result in a small commission to us at no cost to you.
September 2025 Reese Witherspoon Book Club Spoiler
Reese Witherspoon’s Book Club, Hello Sunshine, was the first of the modern celebrity book clubs to catch on in recent years. Started in 2017, her list features thrillers, romances, historical fiction, YA, non-fiction, and modern fiction.
To The Moon and Back
Author: Eliana Ramage
Genre: Literary Fiction
Release Date: September 2, 2025
More info: September 2025 Reese Witherspoon Book Club pick!
Plot
I’ve seen the sticker and I know this is the newest Reese pick — and it’s perfect for fans of Atmosphere and Hidden Figures! It’s all about a woman’s quest to be the first Cherokee astronaut. Steph Harper has dreamed of working for NASA since she was little, and we get to see her thirty-year journey throughout the book, along with a cast of other characters.
You can see the whole book list, ranked, here.
September 2025 Read With Jenna Book Club Spoiler
Jenna Bush Hager started her book club on the Today Show back in the spring of 2019. They are often more literary than Reese’s picks and cover various thought-provoking topics.
Buckeye: A Novel
Author: Patrick Ryan
Year: 2025
Genre: Historical Fiction
More info: September 2025 Read with Jenna Book Club Pick
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 18+
Plot
This is an epic family saga in the Midwest that binds two families together. The story spans from WWII to the late 20th century. An encounter between Cal Jenkins, a man unable to go to war, and Margaret Salt brings two families together for decades to come. We see the families through the post-war boom through the 90s as the secrets of Cal and Margaret’s decision leaves a lasting impact on their families.
Trigger Warnings
Racism, Homophobia, War
Why Kirsten likes it
I wanted to love this story, but I ultimately found the characters to be rather flat. I connected the most with Felix’s character arc, but other characters – especially the women – really felt one dimensional to me. The story was different enough to keep me reading, but I liked this one – I didn’t love it. #gifted by PRH Audio
Find this book in: Read With Jenna Book Club 2025
You can see all of Jenna’s Book Club picks here, where we ranked them.
September 2025 Good Morning America Book Club Spoiler
GMA’s answer to Read with Jenna was to host their own celebrity book club. This one launched in the Fall of 2019 and it’s probably the best one of the bunch.
The Book of Lost Hours
Author: Hayley Gelfuso
Year: 2025
Genre: Historical Magical Realism
More info: September 2025 GMA Book Club Pick
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 15+
Plot
In 1938, Lisabet Levy and her father, a watchmaker, were home on the night of Kristallnacht. Her father leaves to find her brother and puts her inside a place that is time itself. It is where all memories are held in books. This is where Lisabet becomes trapped while she waits for her father, who never returns.
In 1965, Amelia Duquesne is mourning the loss of her uncle Ernest. When a CIA operative finds her and asks for her help in locating a book her uncle was looking for, she is hesitant. When that operative shows her how her uncle’s watch can manipulate time, she is forced to cooperate and hopes that she will find answers.
Why Jackie loves it
I loved this dual timeline historical fiction book. It has everything I love in a book. The plot was nonstop action, the characters felt real, and the story was emotionally charged. I could not put it down. #Gifted by S & S Audio
Find this book in: The Best Good Morning America Books
September 2025 Good Morning America Book Club YA Spoiler
Sisters in the Wind
Author: Angeline Boulley
Year: 2025
Genre: YA Fiction
More info: GMA YA Book Club Pick September 2025, Bestselling Author of Firekeeper’s Daughter and Warrior Girl Unearthed
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 15+
Plot
Lucy Smith’s father died 5 years ago. Lucy has been on the run ever since rather than become a ward of the state. Her father had hoped that his new wife would love and care for Lucy when he was gone, but it quickly became clear that the new Mrs. Smith had no intentions of caring for Lucy.
Now, after a horrible “accident”, Lucy meets Mr. Jameson, who tells her that her father hid her Ojibwe heritage. She has a family she never knew about, including siblings and a grandmother. Lucy must now come to terms with who she really is and why her father hid it from her. This YA book is a mystery about a young woman claiming her heritage. #gifted
Trigger Warnings
Foster care, abuse, neglect, and drug use
Why Jackie loves it
Angeline Boulley is a master storyteller who weaves historical context into her novels. The characters in this book overlap with the characters from her other books. This story is heartbreaking and compelling from the first page. Lucy has a dark past, but her story is one of many children that is overlooked.
Find this book in: GMA Book Club List 2025/ Best Good Morning America Book Club Books
See Jackie’s review of the GMA YA pick below!
For the whole list of GMA books, ranked, check out this post.
September 2025 Oprah Book Club Spoiler
Oprah doesn’t release her book club picks in the same way as the rest of the celebrity book clubs. She picks them when she likes – on no timetable. Her picks often span multiple months for reading and discussion as well. The September 2025 Oprah Book Club pick is below.
All the Way to the River: Love, Loss, and Liberation
Author: Elizabeth Gilbert
Genre: Memoir
Release Date: September 9, 2025
More info: September 2025 Oprah Book Club pick, Author of Eat, Pray, Love
Plot
Elizabeth Gilbert has written her first nonfiction book in 10 years and this is a gripping story of love and addiction. In 2000, Elizabeth met Rayya and the two became inseparable before they realized they were in love. The two started a cycle of addiction and self-destruction. This book looks like a powerful read from the September 2025 book releases.
What to do with the book club spoilers
- Use these spoilers to get on the library hold list before the masses!
- If your library doesn’t have it on a preorder list, ask them to purchase it and your name will be on the top.
- Prefer to buy the book? Place your pre-order now so you can have it on release day!
- Oprah’s pick starts on September 10th, so it might go into October as she generally splits the book into parts for discussion.
Related Content
Epilogue
Which of these books do you plan on reading?
The Best Celebrity Book Clubs
Looking for more of the best celebrity book club picks? We’ve got you covered.
