Best Mystery Books of All Time
I wanted to choose the best mystery books ever written and it was not an easy task. I have looked into every mystery novel Kirsten and I have read to give you a list that will keep you on the edge of your seat and keep you guessing until the end.

Kirsten and I have read many mysteries so picking the best was no easy task. These are well-written, intelligent mysteries with great characters you will want to visit with often.
So, prepare to immerse yourself in the best mystery novels ever written as I reveal the best mystery books of all time, guaranteed to captivate your imagination and leave you craving for more. If you are looking for more, have a look at Cozy Mystery Books.
The Best Mystery Books of All Time
Each colorful block below represents the best book in a subgenre. Click on the arrow to reveal my “best” pick in any category. You’ll also be able to use a page jump to see more books in that section.
The Best New Mystery Book
Mad Mabel by Sally Hepworth- Jump to Section
The Best Cozy Mystery Book
The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman- Jump to Section
The Best Classic Mystery Book
The Complete Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle – Jump to Section
The Best Detective Fiction
Still Life by Louise Penny- Jump to Section
The Best Locked Room/ Closed Circle Mystery
And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie- Jump to Section
Best Puzzle Mystery Book
The Appeal by Janice Hallett- Jump to Section
Best Historical Mystery Book
The Beekeeper’s Apprentice by Laurie R. King- Jump to Section
Best Literary Mystery
The Ciolin Conspiracy by Brendan Slocumb- Jump to Section
The Best YA Mysteries
The Inheritance Game by Jennifer Lynn Barnes- Jump to Section
*Post contains affiliate links. Purchases made through links result in a small commission to us at no cost to you. Some books have been gifted. All opinions are our own.
New Mysteries

Mad Mabel
Author: Sally Hepworth
Year: 2026
Genre: Historical Fiction Mystery
More info: Bestselling author
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 18+
Plot
Elsie Mabel Fitzpatrick is an 81-year-old woman who has worked very hard to conceal her past. No one ever suspects little girls or old ladies of doing anything criminal. When a new little girl moves into Elsie’s neighborhood, she works very hard to become Elsie’s friend. Little does she know that 50 years ago, Elsie was known as mad Mabel, and she hopes that the past will not repeat itself.
Trigger Warnings
Child Abuse, Mental Illness
Why Kirsten loves it
I’m used to Sally Hepworth writing chilling thrillers that keep me guessing, but this story was so much more than that. Instead of a thriller, I was treated to the history of a fascinating woman often associated with death in her past. As Mabel’s story unfolded, my heart went from guarded to wary to absolute tender love for Mabel.
The character arc for Mabel reminded me of that silly saying from the donkey in Shrek – in the best way. The layers of this woman! And I loved the growth of her neighbors, and they learned more about her. This is one of my favorite stories of the year so far – especially with the narrator choice of an old and young Mabel in the audiobook. It really brought the story to life. #gifted by MacMillan Audio and St. Martin’s Press.
Find this book in: Books with Older Protagonists / Best Beach Reads 2026 / Best Mystery Books of 2026 / Best Mystery Books of All Time / Giftable Books

The Secret Lives of Murderers’ Wives
Author: Elizabeth Arnott
Release Date: March 3, 2026
Genre: Thriller
More: March 2026 GMA Book Club Pick
Spice Rating:💋💋
Age Range: 18+
Plot
Beverly, Elsie, and Margot are all wives of convicted killers. The three women form an unlikely friendship while trying to make a new future for themselves. Everyone around them wonders how they could not have known what their husbands were doing. When a new killer hits the news, the three women decide to join forces to catch the killer. Who could be better than people who have shared their lives with one?
Trigger Warnings
description of murder
Why Jackie loves it
This book is well-written and unique, with a cast of characters that I loved. I love the way the women came together. I listened to my copy of this book, and the narrator is fantastic. #gifted from PRH Audio.
Find this book in: Best Fiction Serial Killer Books / Best Mystery Books of 2026 / Books With Secret in the Title / Best Mystery Books of All Time

How to Cheat Your Own Death
Author: Kristen Perrin
Year: 2026
Genre: Mystery
More info: The Castle Knoll Files #3
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 14+
Plot
In the 1960s, Frances is in London, attending university and taking psychology classes, when she crosses paths with Vera, a socialite and artist who quickly becomes her friend. When Vera turns up murdered, Frances becomes a suspect and needs to find a way out of suspicion.
Meanwhile, in the present, Annie is also in London visiting her artist mother, Laura, after a murder just like Vera’s happens just outside Laura’s studios. Clearly, the murders are connected, but can Annie figure out how and solve Vera’s murder in the process?
Why Kirsten loves it
It was fun to see Annie and Frances in London, solving an art crime instead of in their not-so-sleepy country town. I’ve grown to love the main cast of characters for this charming series, and I hope it continues into the future. Indeed, the ending seemed to hint that we would be heading back to Castle Knoll again! Gifted by Putnam.
Find this book in: Best British Mystery Books / Best Mystery Books of 2026 / Books Set in the 1960s / Best Mystery Books of All Time
Cozy Mysteries

Thursday Murder Club
Author: Richard Osman
Year: 2020
Genre: Mystery
More info: Book 1 of 5 in Thursday Murder Club Series
Age Range: 14+
Plot
In a retirement village, in the puzzle room, four septuagenarians meet weekly for the Thursday Murder Club. They discuss and try to solve cold cases. When a local developer is found dead, the Thursday murder club has its first real case.
Soon, the bodies are piling up, and it’s up to the TMC to find the killer and stop them before it’s too late.
Why Jackie loves it
There was not much about this book that I didn’t love. The characters are smart and multi-dimensional. The plot is both intelligent and funny. I easily read this book in two days. This is the perfect cozy mystery book.
Find this book in: Books with Older Protagonists / Cozy Mystery Books / Books to Get Out of a Reading Slump / Novels Set in Retirement Communities / Best Mystery Books of All Time

Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers
Author: Jesse Q. Sutanto
Year: 2023
Genre: Mystery
More info: Vera Wong #1
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 13+
Plot
Vera Wong lives above her tea shop in Chinatown in San Francisco. When she finds a dead body in the shop, she calls the police immediately but also cleans up a bit, uses a Sharpie to trace the body, and takes the flash drive out of the man’s dead hand.
She is sure that she can do a better job of finding the murderer than the police. She comes up with a plan to find the killer and finds four suspects who she grows to care for.
Why Jackie loves it
I loved this mystery book and have recommended this cozy book too many times to count. Vera is easily one of my favorite amateur detectives and the story is simultaneously funny and heartwarming!
Find this book in: Ultimate List of Beach Reads 2023 / Books Like a Man Called Ove / Fiction Books About Tea / Best Cozy Mystery Books / Books with a Name in the Title / Best Mystery Books of All Time

The Maid
Author: Nita Prose
Year: 2022
Genre: Mystery
More info: January 2022 Good Morning America Pick
#1 New York Times Bestseller, EDGAR AWARD Finalist, Anthony Award Winner
Age Range: 14+
Plot
Molly Gray works as a maid in a grand hotel and gets joy from leaving things orderly and pristine. Molly struggles with reading social cues and has had even more trouble since her gran can no longer help.
When Molly finds the body of Mr. Black in a room at the hotel, she becomes a prime suspect and will need all her friends to help her. She calls her friend, Mr. Preston, the doorman at the hotel, for help. His daughter is a lawyer. Soon, it becomes clear that Molly, in her naivete, is involved in a drug scandal as well.
Why Jackie loves it
I loved the description of this book and I hoped it would live up to my expectations. It did that and more. I adored every minute of this story and closed the last page smiling. Molly is such a wonderful character who has more depth than is apparent initially.
Find this book in: Books like Lessons in Chemistry / Best Mystery Books of All Time/ Feel-Good Books / Books for Book Clubs / Best Cozy Mystery Books / Books With Neurodivergent Characters / Adult Versions of Favorite Childhood Books / Beach Reads 2022 / Thrillers and Mysteries Set in Hotels
Best Mystery Novels: Classics

The Complete Sherlock Holmes Collection
Author: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
Year: 1887-1927
Genre: Mystery
More info: International Bestseller
Age Range: 12+
Plot
Sherlock Holmes’ ability to solve each crime is fascinating. His observations are astute and I can never, ever guess who committed the crime.
If you are looking for the best mystery books of all time, Sherlock Holmes cannot be missed. This complete collection has all the short stories and the 4 Holmes novels.
Why Kirsten loves it
I am a HUGE detective story lover and no one does detective stories better than Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. These books have inspired countless adaptations and retellings since their initial publication.
Find this book in: Sherlock Holmes Books / Literary Classics / Best Mystery Books / British Mysteries / Short Stories / Detective Books / The Best Long Books

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd
Author: Agatha Christie
Year: 1924
Genre: Classic Mystery
More info: Hercule Poirot #4
Age Range: 14+
Plot
In this mystery, Poirot has been recruited to solve the murder of Roger Ackroyd in the middle of a small English village.
Why Kirsten loves it
I like Miss Marple, but Hercule Poirot is my favorite Agatha Christie character. I just love this confidence (or cockiness) and the way he solves each murder with flair.
Find this book in: Best Mystery Books of All Time / 70 Agatha Christie Books in Order (+PDF)
Detective Series

Still Life
Author: Louise Penny
Year: 2007
Genre: Mystery
More info: Chief Inspector Armand Gamache #1
Age Range: 13+
Plot
This is the first book in the New York Times best-selling series of Chief Inspector Gamache. I fell in LOVE with the Inspector, the town of Three Pines, a small Canadian village just north of the US, and its residents. Louise Penny CAN WRITE.
The mystery was great (and I didn’t solve it) but what got me the most was Penny’s writing style and reflections on the human psyche. This first Louise Penny book has Chief Inspector Armand Gamache searching a piece of art for clues after the painter, Jane Neal, turns up dead.
Why Jackie loves it
This is one of the best detective books I have ever read. You will fall in love with Three Pines and the people who live there. The wonderful community in this series is the best of what cozy books should be. If you love mystery novels and have not read this series, what are you waiting for?
Find this book in: Louise Penny Books in Order / Best Mysteries of all Time /Jackie’s Favorite Books / Best Winter Books / Adult Versions of Favorite Childhood Books / Louise Penny Characters

Maisie Dobbs
Author: Jacqueline Winspear
Year: 2003
Genre: Historical Mystery
More info: Maisie Dobbs #1
Age Range: 13+
Plot
Maisie Dobbs is not your typical private investigator. For a start, she is a woman working as a PI in 1929. She is a psychologist and a detective who trained under renowned Maurice Blanche a former member of Scotland Yard. She branches out and decides to start her own business.
Maisie’s first case seems like it should be a simple case of infidelity. Instead, it leads her to a murder and back to WWI where she was a nurse. She is smart, thoughtful, and fun to read.
Why Kirsten loves it
I read this cozy mystery novel in one day. It was so refreshing to see post-war England through Maisie’s eyes as she entered a field dominated by men. I cannot wait to read more books in this fabulous series.
Find this book in: Detective Books / Historical Mystery Books / British Mystery Books / Jazz Age Novels / Best Mystery Books of All Time

The Cuckoo’s Calling
Author: Robert Galbraith
Year: 2012
Genre: Mystery
More info: Corman Strike #1
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 18+
Plot
Cormoran Strike is a private investigator on the verge of failure when a client walks through the door with an amazing story. He is the brother of the recently deceased Lulu Landry, a famous supermodel.
Why Kirsten loves it
If I am honest, I would have read this book no matter what because of who wrote it. However, I kept reading the series because I love it. The last book was close to 700 pages so, there was no way I was reading that if I wasn’t totally invested in these characters.
Why Jackie loves it
Rowling has a way of starting small, introducing you to characters, and sucking you in. Cormoran Strike is the exact opposite of Chief Inspector Gamache. He is flawed and cranky but, you will love him just the same.
Find this book in: British Mystery Books / Detective Books / Best Mystery Books of All Time
Locked Room Mystery and Closed Circle Mystery

And Then There Were None
Author: Agatha Christie
Year: 1939
Genre: Classic Mystery
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 16+
Plot
A mysterious person is trying to right the wrongs of the past by luring unsuspecting criminals to a deserted island…and then murdering them one by one. But who is the killer? Why are they killing? And just how long have they been stalking their prey? You have to figure out whodunit in this unreliable narrator book.
Why Kirsten loves it
This Agatha Christie book is one of the best stories she has EVER written. It was fast-paced, totally engaging and I did not see the ending coming. Each murder was more clever then the one before. Check out the black and white movie based on the book. It’s great!
Why Jackie loves it
A classic for a reason, Agatha Christie broke the mold with this book. It’s one of the most well-plotted mysteries I’ve ever read.
Find this book in: Unreliable Narrator Book / Best Classic Novels / Historical Mystery Books / Agatha Christie Books in Order / Best Mystery Books of All Time/ Locked Room Mysteries / Books with Numbers in the Title

Everyone in This Bank Is a Thief
Author: Benjamin Stevenson
Year: 2026
Genre: Mystery
More info: Ernest Cunningham Book 4 of 4
Age Range: 14+
Plot
This is a twisty new locked room mystery. Ten suspects in a bank, one murder, and more than one plan to rob the bank. Who is stealing what? Are they willing to kill for what they want?
Why Kirsten loves it
This was my first Ernest Cunningham story, even though it’s the fourth in the series, so it can absolutely be read as a standalone! I love that every person was stealing something from this bank, and the high-stakes countdown throughout. It was a fun, fair game mystery that had me trying to solve everything right along with Ernest!
The audiobook version was wonderful as well; the narrator did an excellent job. #gifted by HarperAudio and Mariner Books.
Find this book in: Locked Room Mysteries / Novels About Thieves / Best Mystery Books of All Time

Anxious People
Author: Fredrik Backman
Year: 2019
Genre: Fiction
More info: New York Times Bestselling Author
Age Range: 16+
Plot
Fredrik Backman is a master storyteller and he does it again with this book. He somehow manages to tackle difficult subjects without trivializing them but still allowing them to be humorous.
This book is a story of a bank robbery gone very wrong and the idiots in the story (his word, not mine) who are taken hostage after the failed robbery. While the police are interviewing each of the hostages to find the robbers, they become more confused after each interview. It is also a story about compassion, human relationships, and the daily struggles that we all have.
Why Jackie loves it
I love how Fredrik Backman’s books show the good in people despite the flaws that make them human. Backman writes so many different kinds of books but they all have so much heart. Backman weaves themes of love, friendship, and compassion throughout all his books.
Adaptations
Angelina Jolie is set to produce and star in the movie adaptation of this book. A Swedish adaptation came out in 2021 and is on Netflix. The movie will be released on November 26, 2026.
Find this book in: Books Like A Man Called Ove / New Year’s Eve Books / Best Beach Reads / Locked Room Mysteries / Best Books of 2020 / Ultimate List of Feel-Good Reads / Best Books in Translation / Books Becoming Movies / Novels About Thieves / Best Mystery Books of All Time
Puzzle Mysteries

The Appeal
Author: Janice Hallett
Year: 2022
Genre: Thriller
More info: International Bestseller
Best Book of 2022 by The New York Times
Crime Writer Association New Blood Dagger Award
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 16+
Plot
I was utterly charmed by this unique murder mystery book! The premise is great – a detective duo has been given a stack of correspondence (text and emails) and asked to read through and determine who was murdered, why, and who was wrongly accused.
Of course, we readers get to come along for the ride – reading their post-it notes or texts to each other as they try to solve the mystery. I was desperately trying to solve it along with them but I was stumped!
The ending was truly shocking and the many twists and turns had me flying through the story. I read part of it and listened to part. Both formats make for a wonderful experience! This is one I’ll be recommending this pick from the ultimate list of mystery books for years to come!
Trigger Warnings
Cancer
Why Kirsten loves it
This is the first of Janice Hallett’s book and it firmly placed her in the “must-read” author category. The format of this book is brilliant and her other books are equally entertaining, well-written, and brilliantly plotted.
Find this book in: Detective Books / British Mystery Books/ Epistolary Novels / Janice Hallett Books in Order / The Best Audiobooks of All Time / Beach Reads 2022 / Best Mystery Books of All Time

Mr. Penumbra’s 24 Hour Book Store
Author: Robin Sloan
Year: 2012
Genre: Fiction
More info: Mr. Penumbra’s 24-Hour Bookstore #1, New York Times Bestseller
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 16+
Plot
This was a light and enjoyable magical realism book. When Clay takes a job in a bookstore, he thinks he will be selling books. He doesn’t realize that the “wayback” of the store is more like a library to an elite group of readers. Mr. Penumbra’s bookstore is exactly the type of store that you will never want to leave.
Why Kirsten loves it
This book was not what I was expecting. There was a lot more mystery and action than I thought and a little more magic as well. The characters developed and changed and the story moved quickly.
Why Jackie loves it
This is a book about a bookstore which is always something to love, but this book has puzzles to solve before you can understand why the bookstore is so special.
Find this book in: Books About Puzzles / Books About Bookstores / Books About Secret Societies / Best Mystery Books of All Time

The Fellowship of Puzzle Makers
Author: Samuel Burr
Year: 2024
Genre: Mystery
More info: National Bestseller
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 16+
Plot
Clayton Stumper was raised by a group of puzzle makers in the commune where he was left as a baby. When the woman who raised him dies, she leaves him with one more puzzle to solve.
The solution will give him answers about his past and the secrets of his birth as well as point give him directions for his future.
Why Jackie loves it
I read this book in a day and found it even more delightful than the description. It was a medium-paced book, however, the puzzles within are engaging and the dual-timeline story made it unputdownable. I loved this 5-star read. #gifted
Find this book in: Best Puzzle Books for Adults / Best New Mystery Books of 2024 / Best Fiction Books of 2024 / Best Mystery Books of All Time
Historical Mysteries

The Beekeeper’s Apprentice
Author: Laurie R. King
Year: 1994
Genre: Historical Mystery
More info: Mary Russell and Sherlock Holmes #1
Age Range: 14+
Plot
This one is for all the Sherlock fans out there. It takes place after the classic canon ends with the introduction of the retired Holmes and his new neighbor – Mary Russell. When an American Senator’s daughter is kidnapped, Holmes and his protege are called to help Scotland Yard with the case.
Why Kirsten loves it
I adore this historical mystery book series, as does my dad who is a mystery reader exclusively. This series is has more than a dozen books already, each better than the last. I love seeing Mary and Sherlock’s relationship change over the series as Mary hones her skills.
Find this book in: Sherlock Holmes Fiction / Best Historical Mystery Books / British Mystery Books / Detective Books / Best Mystery Books of All Time

Etiquette for Lovers and Killers
Author: Anna Fitzgerald Healy
Year: 2025
Genre: Historical Mystery
More info: A Beyond the Bookends Most Anticipated July 2025 Book Release
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range:16+
Plot
This novel is a historical fiction set in the 60s, a cozy mystery, and a romance all tied up into one book! And it’s set in Maine as well. Billie McCadie lives with her grandparents and lives vicariously through the characters in the books she gets from the library. She loves epic love stories and mysteries. She is confused when she receives a letter addressed to Gertrude asking for her hand in marriage with a diamond ring. She is even more surprised when Gertrude is found dead and Billie is one of the last to see her alive.
Now her boring life becomes much more interesting, especially when she must take it upon herself to find the murderer. Everyone is hiding secrets, bodies are piling, and Billie is receiving concerning phone calls. Is she safe? Is she a suspect?
Why Jackie loves it
These characters are so much fun. They are unique and surprising, which makes this an easy read. I loved the glimpse into the 60s with the yachts and parties and the mystery was well-plotted. I had no idea who murdered Gertrude. #gifted from Putnam
Find this book in: Best Beach Reads 2025 / Books Set in Maine / Cozy Mystery Books / Books Set in the 1960s / RomCozy Books / Best Mystery Books of 2025 / Best Historical Mystery Books / Best Mystery Books of All Time

Plot
A young girl is abandoned on a ship headed to Australia. When she arrives, the only thing in her possession is a suitcase with some clothes and a book of fairy tales. The dock master and his wife adopt Nell and tell her the story of her arrival in Australia on her 21st birthday. She goes back to England on a quest to find her lost identity.
Unsuccessful, her granddaughter later takes up the search and tries to assemble the pieces of her grandmother’s mystery and unlock the secrets of her past.
Trigger Warnings
Child Death, Infertility
Why Kirsten loves it
I was swept away by this story and found myself dreaming of Cornwall while reading. This gothic fiction is a perfect book for fall.
Find this book in: Cozy Books / Family Saga / Books set in Cornwall / Historical Mystery / British Books / Best Cozy Mystery Books / Fiction Books About Gardens and Gardening / Kate Morton Books in Order and Ranked / Best Mystery Books of All Time
Literary Mysteries

Violin Conspiracy
Author: Brendan Slocumb
Year: 2022
Genre: Mystery
More info: February 2022 GMA Book Club Pick
Age Range: 16+
Plot
WHAT A MYSTERY! The Violin Conspiracy opens with a man’s 14-million-dollar Stradivarius violin being stolen, and the drama doesn’t let up.
Ray McMillian is a young black musical prodigy who just so happens to have inherited his grandpa’s busted-up fiddle – which turns out to be a rare violin built by one of the greats. But when the origins of the violin come into question, along with Ray’s claim to the instrument, the plot keeps thickening.
Trigger Warnings
Racism
Why Kirsten loves it
Truly the story was a gripping page-turner I could not put down. Slocumb’s ability to weave a multi-faceted tale was astounding. When it comes to novels about music, this is a must-read mystery book!
Find this book in: Best Audiobooks of 2022 / Novels About Music / GMA Book Club List 2022 / Best Mystery Books of All Time

Where the Crawdads Sing Deluxe Edition
Author: Dehlia Owens
Year: 2018
Genre: Historical Fiction
More info: September 2018 Reese Witherspoon Book Club Pick, Season 7 Queen Camilla’s Book Club Pick
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 16+
Plot
The book begins when a body is found in a North Carolina marsh and is identified as Chase Andrews. The story moves between the past and the present to tell the story of Kya Clark, The Marsh Girl, who is a suspect in the murder.
Kya Clark, The Marsh Girl, is abandoned first by her mother, then by her siblings, and eventually by her father at a very young age. She is forced to fend for herself in the marshes, away from society.
With the help of two beloved friends, she learns to care for herself but not without experiencing cruelty and violence. Then, she finds herself faced with murder charges and is forced to confront her secrets and past that have shaped her into the woman that she has become.
Trigger Warnings
Abandonment, Domestic and child abuse, assault
Why Jackie loves it
I admit that when I saw the description of this coming-of-age book, I was not sold. A trusted individual, who has never steered me wrong in the past, gave me an advanced copy so, I took the leap. And wow, am I glad I did. I read this book and then recommended it to everyone I knew. It is a story about love, nature, and perseverance.
Why Kirsten loves it
This is a novel that is so much more than the sum of its parts. It is part mystery and part historical fiction that shows the importance of human connections.
Find this book in: Books About Poverty and Its Impact / Best Mystery Books of All Time / Books Like Where the Crawdads Sing / Book Club for Where the Crawdads Sing/ Books with Food in the Title / Books That Will Emotionally Wreck You / Best Reese Witherspoon Books / Books Set in the 1960s / The Best Audiobooks of All Time / Books Like Eleanor Oliphant

The Thirteenth Tale
Author: Diane Setterfield
Year: 2006
Genre: Gothic Mystery
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 16+
Plot
A young biographer is called to help a reclusive author of 12 books tell her life story. In the process, she learns there is a thirteenth tale after all. It’s a gothic romance, a mystery, and a story about family ties all in one.
Why Kirsten loves it
I adored this gothic story when I read it on vacation a few years back. The setting and gothic vibes make this book perfect for a chilly autumn day. I was swept into this story and read it to completion at 3 a.m.
Find this book in: Best Historical Mystery Books / Best Mystery Books of All Time / Books With Numbers in the Title / Historical Fiction Books About Books
YA Mysteries

The Inheritance Games
Author: Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Year: 2020
Genre: YA Mystery
More info: Book 1 of 5: The Inheritance Games
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 14+
Plot
I knew I had to read this YA mystery series after it was compared to one of my favorite middle-grade mystery books, The Westing Game.
In this story, Avery, a poor orphan is told she’s just inherited a billionaire’s fortune. His family is determined to get to the money, but Avery has bigger fish to fry – the riddles and puzzles the deceased Tobias Hawthorne left behind for her to solve. As she teams up with unlikely allies, she’s forced to figure out who is a friend or foe. In order to receive the money, she must follow the clues.
Why Kirsten loves it
I flew through this story and can’t wait to get my hands on the rest of the trilogy!
Why Jackie loves it
I loved everything about this series, from the characters to the plot to the mystery of “why”.
Adaptation Information
Amazon purchased the rights to this book intending to make a TV series with Lionsgate Television. This announcement comes after it had stalled in production.
Find this book in: Books for 13-year-olds / Best Mystery Books for Teens / Best Puzzle Books / Cozy Mystery Books / Fun Books for Teens / Books Becoming TV Series / Best Books About Siblings / Best Mystery Books of All Time

Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie
Author: Alan Bradley
Year: 2009
Genre: YA Historical Mystery
More info: Flavia De Luce #1
Age Range: 12+
Plot
This is the first book in the Flavia De Luce series. This 11-year-old aspiring chemist is a wonderful heroine who is smart and precocious. In this first book, it is 1950 and Flavia has a love of poisons. When she finds a man taking his last breath in a cucumber patch, she is not scared at all, rather, she delights in solving the mystery.
Why Kirsten loves it
Flavia is an absolute delight to read as she’s easily one of the most unique characters in a mystery series. My dad recommended this series to me. I read it, loved it, and promptly passed it on to my 12-year-old. I love that this story works for readers of all generations.
Why Jackie loves it
This is one of the best first mystery books for younger readers as it does not have violence.
Find this book in: Best Historical Mystery Books / Best Mystery Books of All Time / Best Books for 13-year-olds / British Mystery Books / Best Cozy Mystery Books / Fun Books for Teens / Books with Food in the Title / Books with Child Narrators

One of Us is Lying
Author: Karen M. McManus
Year: 2017
Genre: YA Thriller
More info: Named one of the ten best books of the year by Entertainment Weekly
Spice Rating:💋
Age Range: 14+
Plot
This YA locked room mystery is one of my favorites on the list. It is the breakfast club meets murder and I am obsessed. The Brain, the Beauty, the Criminal, The Athlete, and the Outcast are all in detention together. Only Simon, the outcast, is dead before he can leave the room.
With everyone holding onto secrets and everyone with a motive, can you figure out who did it?
Why Jackie loves it
This is a mystery and psychological thriller wrapped up in one. This is one book where you will not guess the ending.
Find this book in: Best Psychological Thriller Books /Locked Room Mysteries to Die For / Best Mystery Books of All Time / Books with Unreliable Narrators / Books With Numbers in the Title / YA Thriller Books
Expert Tip
Not al mysteries are created equally. Here are some tips to choose your next favorite read
- Look at my subheadings to see what kind of mystery you are in the mood for.
- Are you a “Kirsten” or a “Jackie”? Have a look at who read the book and why we like it to help you pick.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best mystery books of all time?
Patricia Highsmith, Raymond Chandler, and Samuel Dashiell Hammett dominated mystery books from the 1920s through the 1980s. Some classic authors like Sir Arthur Conan Doyle have proven that some books withstand the test of time.
Since then, new authors have made names for themselves like Louise Penny, Dan Brown, and Karen McManus.
Related Content
Epilogue
Do you like our list of the best mystery books of all time?
